News / Latest

“Tough on crime” – The real impact on our youth

“Tough on crime” – The real impact on our youth

ABC reporter Kirstie Wellauer has recently written an article urging the government to intervene and break the cycle of crime in the youth justice system.

The article gives us insight into the reality of our Country’s ‘tough on crime’ stance, citing an open letter initiated by the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Service.

The open letter contains anecdotes from Zach* who has spent time in Youth Detention, and the lasting impacts they have been left to cope with as a young adult. Strikingly, the overwhelming impression appears to be that Youth Detention is ‘breeding criminals’.

The letter itself has many signatories, and as part of the solution calls for more investment in mental health. The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists backs this call, noting that: “mental health professionals could break the cycle of crime if they were involved early enough.”

In Australia our justice system, in particular our prison system, focuses largely on punishment and the concept of general deterrence (that is, deterring the general population from committing crime). There is less of a focus on rehabilitation.

Read the article published in the ABC News here which provides a ‘watch this space’ moment.

We’ll see if it drives any change.

Written by Solicitor Taylor Falting
DISCLAIMER: This is information only and should not be construed as legal advice. This information is correct as at 16.01.2026. Always get specific legal advice tailored to your specific circumstances.

Our Team

Meet our team

Craig Caldicott began practising in criminal law in 1979, Emily Cousins in 2014, Taylor Falting in 2018 and Nathan Ramos in 2020. Both Emily and Taylor have worked with Craig and been under his mentorship since the beginning of their careers.

Principal Criminal Lawyer

Craig Caldicott OAM has appeared as counsel and instructing solicitor in many high-profile cases interstate and in South Australia.

Criminal Lawyer

Emily is a highly acclaimed Criminal Lawyer with expertise in complex cases and a reputation as one of South Australia’s top legal minds.

Criminal Lawyer

Taylor specialises in Criminal Law and is admitted to practice in South Australia and Queensland. She also has High Court experience.

Criminal Lawyer

Nathan is a Criminal Lawyer and was admitted to the Supreme Court of South Australia in 2020.